Saturday, August 15, 2015

The most blasphemous doctrine ever invented - Part 1

I wanted to write a follow up article to the first one, giving a sort of a list of some important ideas in Bible which I strongly disagree with. But before that I want to write about the most outrageous belief in Christianity... something that bothers me no end. Some other religions believe in this as well but since I was a Christian and I only know well about Christianity, I would stick to talking about it from a Christian point of view.

Blasphemy against God - a Christian obsession

Most of us would be familiar with the idea of blasphemy against God. Simply it is something that insults God.. a thought, a spoken sentence or an idea. Normally we would think only a person who doesn't believe in a particular God would say blasphemous things against that God. But often in history, the ideas of some people who absolutely revere their God, are viewed by disagreeing counterparts as being blasphemous against the very God those people revere. And some doctrines of certain groups of Christianity are viewed by other groups as blasphemous, like the doctrine demeans God somehow. For example, if a group views Jesus as being lower than God the Father in status, another group might call it a blasphemy against Jesus. This problem is not a minor one in Christianity. Christian groups often blame each other for beliefs which are supposedly blasphemous. Some zealous Christians are almost obsessed with these things.

If we think about it rationally, we would wonder how a believing Christian could say something deliberately to insult the God he worships. Well, the most frequently proposed reason in Christianity for such a thing would be "deception by the devil." Sometimes the disagreeing parties may say something slightly more logical like the person is being naive and he doesn't understand how his idea is an insult to God. Actually if you make a list of doctrines viewed by many Christian groups as blasphemous and analyze them a bit deeply, trying to think from the point of view of the person who proposed the said doctrines, you would find that the doctrines are not that malicious, like not even remotely. But there is a doctrine which is widely accepted by most Christian groups. A doctrine which would be deemed as a total insult to God by any person with even average thinking ability if he applied just a little common sense to analyze its implications.

A doctrine straight from hell

So what is this doctrine, that I view as the most blasphemous doctrine ever invented? It looks to me like it came straight out of hell.. and it is the DOCTRINE OF THE EXISTENCE OF HELL!  The idea that there exists a place, full of fire where souls will suffer unbearable pain and torture FOR ETERNITY as punishment by God.

Now, the people who believe in hell (that means most Christians) have some passages in Bible to support their doctrine. But for every verse of Bible they can show to prove the existence of hell, those who don't believe in its existence can show one hundred verses to disprove it. But let us leave the Bible for a while and apply just some basic common sense. The doctrine of hell would be absolutely wrong on so many levels and for so many different reasons if just a little common sense is applied.

Any reasonable man would agree that the extent of punishment should be proportionate to the extent of the crime committed. The punishment for stealing a hundred dollars can not be the same as the punishment for stealing a million dollars. If that basic rule is applied to the doctrine of hell, not even the most wicked person to ever live on earth would deserve the punishment of hell because every man is a mortal and his ability to commit atrocities is finite. A person can not be given infinite punishment for a finite crime. I have seen some believers in hell defend this with the argument that "Since God is infinite and every sin is a sin against God, the punishment should be infinite as well." A whole separate article would not be enough to point out the absurdities in that argument. It only shows the fact that when a person believes in something, he would be blind to its absurdities. I know it from first hand experience. I believed in the existence of hell for a long time without really giving any serious thought to whether it made any sense. After I started to really question it with an open mind and found how outrageous it is, now I can't understand how I believed in this absurd idea for such a long time without realizing its ridiculousness.

So, without going to Bible, we can logically ask how God can punish anyone with hell fire. Charles Taze Russell, one of the most prominent Christian leaders to deny the doctrine of hell, got this excellent logically sound question in his mind when he thought about hell  "If there is a hell, how can an all knowing God be even justified in creating man when He knew in advance that the man is going to end up in hell?" All Christians agree in the idea that God is all powerful, and all loving. The doctrine of hell requires one of these two things to be untrue. If hell exists, either God does not want man to go hell but is not powerful enough to stop it, or God is all powerful but unwilling to use His power to stop man from going to hell which implies He is not all loving.

But, the doctrine of hell doesn't even deserve this kind of analysis. How can anyone honestly believe God created something of such unimaginable cruelty? If I were God I would be more offended by such an idea than anything else. I mean, think about it. Christians think God would be offended when people worship some other god. Christians think God would be offended if you think God doesn't exist. Christians think God would be offended by any kind of imagination of God that differs from their own view of God. But God would not be offended when people think He is such a cruel monster? I find this the most blasphemous doctrine ever invented.

Coming back to the Bible, let us do a bit of analysis to see if the doctrine of hell has good Biblical basis. Random verses from Bible can be assembled to give an illusion that Bible backs up the doctrine of hell. But when taken in whole, the doctrine of hell doesn't fit into the Bible's narrative. Lets go to the beginning of everything. God told Adam that if he eats the forbidden fruit, he would die. No mention of eternal hell fire or even temporary hell fire. Adam went on to eat the forbidden fruit anyways and brought death on whole humanity. Over time people became more and more wicked and by the time of Noah, God could no longer bear the enormity of human wickedness that He actually felt sad for even creating man. So God decided to destroy them except the family of Noah whom God found to be the only man good enough to escape punishment. Again, no mention of hell fire... just God killing almost everyone on earth. Things go on like this and until the time of Moses God had not given a detailed book of instructions to follow and to know what God is all about. When God gave Moses the commandments, it became the standard until the arrival of Jesus. As we know, the books of Moses along with the books of prophets and some other books became the Bible of the Jews known as the Old Testament. And all through the Old Testament, the Bible mostly talks about the present life. There is almost no mention of an afterlife. It is basically like "If you follow my commandments, you will have a good life on earth. Otherwise I will punish you with all kinds of things IN THIS LIFE." No mention of hell or heaven. Even if you go through the passages in the books of prophets where God was full of anger at the people of Israel and telling them how wicked they were and how He was going to punish them, it was always some horrible descriptions of sufferings in THIS WORLD and death. There is not a single mention of punishment even remotely looking like hell fire in afterlife.

After Jesus arrived on scene, He seemed to give a higher revelation of God. He replaced the Old Testament's tit-for-tat ethics with a merciful, self-less, forgiving higher level of ethics. He showed God as a loving father who is full of mercy and forgiveness and asked the people to emulate their Father in heaven. Surely, Jesus taught there is an afterlife which the Old Testament barely made a mention of. But the idea of an afterlife in heaven does not need a counterpart in hell! It doesn't go well with Jesus' higher revelation of a merciful, loving, forgiving God who cares for nothing but the good of His creations. If Jesus taught about a loving God full of mercy in contrast to the often seen vengeful version of God full of anger in the Old Testament, how can we accept that this higher revelation of God also teaches that this God is going to mete out an infinite times more horrible punishment than anything ever mentioned in the Old Testament? It doesn't make sense if we think about this. After Jesus arrived, the angry God of Old Testament suspended His anger and vengeance temporarily and became a god perfect in love. Jesus said "Then your reward will be great, and you will be children of the Most High, because he is kind to the ungrateful and wicked. 36 Be merciful, just as your Father is merciful." So this angry God temporarily became kind to the ungrateful and wicked and temporarily became merciful only to later throw these ungrateful and wicked into a much greater punishment than anything He vowed in the Old Testament. That is faked mercy. Not true mercy. This makes one wonder if the Old Testament version of God is actually preferable. So it would be inconceivable to think that Jesus taught hell fire because it would mean Jesus was incoherent in His teaching of God.

The Just God

Throughout the Bible, we find that God takes great pride in saying He is a just God. His punishments are all justified. Some people seem to think that since God is God, anything He does must be correct. Like, we can't really question God, He has the right to do anything. If that is the case, then there is really no point in God proclaiming Himself to be just. If He is entitled to do anything why would He say He is just? It clearly means that there is something called Justice and God is bound by that principle. God says He doesn't defy the principle of Justice and He takes great pride in declaring so. And many people throughout the Bible praises God for being so just. We can clearly see that this implies that God has given all people a sense of what is just and what is not and God is seen by these people based on their own sense of justice that He is very just. 

Then, how does this totally just God come up with something that is totally unjust? How can He give people a punishment that is totally disproportionate to their crime? But many Christians don't have a clear idea of what is good and what is just. They often seem to think "God is good to me. So He is good. It doesn't matter what He does to everyone else." If God is good, He has to be consistently and unbiasedly good to everyone. Being good to a selective group of people is not enough to be considered good. Even the most wicked person on earth can be good to some people. Jesus said God is the only good person in the universe. So His goodness has to be greater than the goodness of the best man on earth. It is impossible to reconcile the idea of hell with a perfectly good and loving God. 

(To be continued)


Sunday, August 9, 2015

The primary root of problems in the Christian religion

Disclaimer
Firstly, let me make it clear that I don't believe in any religion anymore. So why am I writing this article? I was a Christian for a long time. I have a fairly good idea about what the Bible says. I had been disturbed by many things that plague Christianity. And I have given a lot of thought to those things and have had come to some conclusions. I am putting out those ideas here, just in case they might help some Christians get answers to the questions they fear to ask anyone and become more comfortable in their lives' journey as Christians.

Preface
Born as a Christian, from my young days well into my adulthood for like 3 decades, I belonged to a strict kind of Church. And probably like many Christians who attend such churches I was totally oblivious to the reality outside my church, strongly believing that only my church had the correct understanding of Bible. I was thinking other churches and their members didn't know much about the Bible and didn't do much as Christians as well. I was blind to reality until I got out of my church and got some knowledge about what people of other churches are doing. This is one of the big problems of being a staunch believer of any particular kind of faith. A staunch believer will be unable to see anything contrary to his belief even if it is there right before his eyes.

Anyways, I got out of my bubble  and got to know that other groups of Christians are as good as the group I belonged to. Though they have different interpretations and different doctrines, they are not any less than my group in terms of Biblical knowledge, putting good principles into practice or any other parameter used in evaluating a group of people. Over time I gained a more realistic and broader view of the Christian world. This led to the realization of an unfortunate problem prevalent in Christianity which is the subject of this post.

The problem
The message of Christianity (also called the gospel) is supposed to be God's glorious solution out of His infinite wisdom to the fall of humans and the evils it created. In Jesus Christ's words, His disciples will be a group of people strongly united by divine love for one another, shining forth like a beacon of hope to the dark wretched world. Jesus particularly said this perfect unity of love will be the sign of His disciples to the world. But what we actually have now is a Christian world broken into innumerable sections. Each section believes all other sections are wrong in their understanding of Jesus' message. Most sections even believe they are the only ones going to heaven and everyone else is going to end up in hell. Most sections have such vigorous belief in their own doctrines that they have feelings bordering on hatred towards others. Different groups just don't get along.

What is more mind-blogging is a little fact you would find out if you study the beliefs of different groups. The fact is, some groups really don't differ from each other that much in their set of beliefs. The small differences deal with things that are totally irrelevant to the practical life of a Christian. Still they think such negligible differences are enough to break up with each other and declare each other worthy of hell. This pathetic state of affairs made me think what went wrong. Why the Bible didn't teach an unambiguous message? Why couldn't the Christians come to a consensus regarding the meaning of the Bible? You would be absolutely justified to ask how this can be God's glorious solution to the whole world if Christians can't make up their minds about what God really meant. This had been in my mind for a long time. My understanding of Bible evolved.. or my view of Bible evolved as I tried to put the pieces together. And something struck my mind... which gave me an idea of what could be the reason for these infinite divisions in Christianity.

The reason - in my view
There are so many different sections in Christianity, each with its own set of beliefs. This leads us to the question, "Is there any belief which is common to all sections of Christianity?" The answer to that question would be... there are a few, e.g salvation comes through the work of Jesus.

And there is another very important belief, which is common to all sections of Christianity, possibly with very few exceptions like the Mormons.  That belief is that "The Bible is the absolute infallible word of God and every single word of the Bible is inspired by God." You can't even ignore a single word of the Bible. When you think about it, isn't it incredible that everyone is claiming that they believe in every single word of the Bible yet they are all disagreeing with each other as to what it means? Perhaps, this particular belief is the reason for all those divisions? I will try to explain how this belief could have caused the numerous divisions in Christianity.


The Bible is not infallible - in my view
The Bible is a collection of books by different authors written over a long period of time. Though believers of the infallibility of Bible claim that God inspired all those different authors and since God is all-knowing and He won't contradict Himself, the Bible is coherent throughout and has no contradictions. But this claim is not substantiated by an examination of the text of Bible. Even a casual reading of the Bible with an open mind will show that Bible has many contradictions in it. There are contradictions in minor details and there are also contradictions in major details.  I am not going to give a list of such contradictions here but such lists are easily available online.

If we study the different books of the Bible well, we will be able to see that different authors had their own thoughts and it is reflected in their writings. One famous example will be the idea of Faith vs Works in the epistles of St.Paul and St.James which led to Martin Luther not having a high view of the epistle of St.James.
Now, most Christians will be very uncomfortable with the idea that the Bible is not infallible. They won't be able to accept it. They would see it like such an idea would invalidate Christianity itself. But that doesn't need to be the case.

Jesus didn't propose the idea
In the Old Testament, we find that God wrote the commandments with His own hand and gave it to Moses. It was also commanded in the Old Testament that every king should have a copy of the Old Testament and read it properly and follow it. In those times, before printing press was invented, it was not easy for everyone to have a copy of the book. But people used to gather in places to hear the books read out to them.

But in the New Testament, we don't find anywhere Jesus instructing His disciples to write down all His teachings into a book and follow it. Most Christians don't even know the person who decided which books should be included in the New Testament. Why would God require anyone to put his whole trust in the arbitrary selection of some random person they don't even know? One might ask "if that is the case, then what is the alternative? what should one follow? how will one know what God wants him to do?" For this question we can find the answer in New Testament itself.

Jesus didn't appeal to the authority of Old Testament
Preachers often talk about how Jesus defeated the temptations of Satan using quotations from the Old Testament. They also refer to the places where Jesus said not even a single letter in the Old Testament will fail. But lets look at something very important to the Christians... the most famous of Jesus' sermons.. the Sermon on the Mount!

If you read through the long sermon from Matthews chapter 5 through chapter 7, you will find that Jesus never used any scripture from the Old Testament to prove what He was teaching. He quoted a few scriptures from Old Testament only to say that He was gonna give them something higher.. like it is allowed in the Old Testament to hate your enemies but He wanted His disciples to love their enemies. Besides those scriptures whose teachings Jesus superseded with His higher level teachings, Jesus never appealed to the authority of Old Testament scriptures to prove what He was saying. But.... HE APPEALED TO THE COMMON SENSE OF PEOPLE! He asks if a human father would give bad things to his son and then challenges the people to use their common sense "If evil humans know how to do good things to their children, how much more surely the Heavenly Father would do good things to His children?"  He talks about how birds don't toil like humans and yet God feeds them all and tells the people God would take care of them as well likewise. He repeatedly asked people to use their common sense instead of quoting from the Bible to prove what He said.

The Sermon on the Mount is not the only place where Jesus didn't quote from Old Testament. We find a consistency in His way of teaching. When the Jews questioned Him about the issue of divorce Jesus simply said "Moses let you do that because of your hardheartedness!" Think about it... Jesus is saying here that this particular verse WAS NOT INSPIRED. In another place, when Jews argued with Jesus about the Sabbath day, Jesus appealed to common sense again. He said "Sabbath was made for man, not the other way round."
When they brought a woman caught in adultery, Jesus said "If any one among you is without sin, let him cast the first stone." Now, this condition was not set forth in the Old Testament. Jesus was again appealing to the common sense. So what is happening here? How can Jesus go against the Old Testament like this when He said He was there to do the will of the very God of the Old Testament? Did God change His mind suddenly?

Jesus was actually showing Old Testament was not to be taken literally. It is not the letters, but the spirit in which the letters were written. We can find support for this throughout the Old Testament itself. Moses, after teaching the people of Israel all these commandments of God, had this very enlightening thing to say. "Don't ask who will bring the word of God to us. It is close to your hearts." That is, each person knows in his heart what is right and what is wrong. He doesn't need to rigidly follow a book blindly following some interpretation of that book without even knowing why he has to do a particular thing. This same idea is echoed again in the New Testament in much stronger terms. In the book of Hebrews it is written that God had done away with the Old covenant. God had introduced a New covenant under which God says He would write His commandments directly into the hearts of people and that NOBODY WILL NEED TO BE TAUGHT BY ANOTHER PERSON WHAT TO DO. It also means nobody will need to rely on a book to know what to do. Has the New covenant come into effect or not? I don't think any Christian will argue that the New covenant is still waiting to be enforced.

St.Paul said, the Old covenant brought only death and the New covenant brought life. And he also said "The letters kills. The spirit gives life."  In my view, the letter DID KILL Christianity. All Christians trying to literally follow a supposedly infallible book have failed obviously.


The example of Martin Luther
I think, Christians need to look how the great reformer Martin Luther approached the Bible. If it was not for Martin Luther, most Christians won't even be holding the Bible, inventing new interpretations all the time and arguing with each other over what the Bible says. But the man who gave the Bible to the common man, approached Bible differently from the common man.

Martin Luther read the Bible with a critical eye. He set aside a good chunk of Old Testament as Apocrypha. He didn't hesitate to criticize the epistle of St.James because St.James stressed the importance of works which was against the belief of Martin Luther. I actually tend to agree with St.James but I would say Martin Luther had the right attitude. Martin Luther wanted to remove the book of Revelations from the New Testament because he thought the book didn't make much sense.


Some more thoughts
Before I finish this, I want to add some more thoughts. I want to go back to a statement I made earlier. Most people don't even know who decided which books should be in the New Testament. And how this person decided which books should be in the New Testament?

Consider the book of Philemon. It was a personal letter from St.Paul to a friend regarding a particular matter. How can this be a book inspired by God meant for all people? Surely that book cannot be followed word for word. It was never meant to be used like that.

In Second Thessalonians St.Paul says "Don’t you remember that when I was with you I used to tell you these things? And now you know what is holding him back, so that he may be revealed at the proper time." Here Paul was referring to something he had already mentioned to the recipients of this epistle. But he hadn't explained what that something was. So if we assume St.Paul wrote this book for all of us, he would be guilty of omitting some information from us.

Similarly, St.John mentions twice in his epistles that he has many things to say but he doesn't want to write them down. If his epistles are inspired infallible word of God, how can he omit many things he wanted to say?

My own conclusion
With all these thoughts in my mind, I came to a conclusion that the primary error of Christians is taking Bible so literally. They tried to make a coherent set of ideas from a collection of books which are not coherent. So they had to invent interpretations to somehow make the contradicting scriptures agree with each other. When attempting that, different groups came up with different interpretations and each group insisted their interpretation is the correct one leading to the breaking up of what should have been a single group of Christians. If they had followed Jesus' advice of putting first things first, they would have given more importance to the unity of Christians rather than strict adherence to a particular interpretation. Now what they seemed to have achieved is making the earnest prayer of Jesus that His disciples should be united like Himself and His father... a big failure! And they also lost the primary sign Jesus gave for others to identify His disciples, "loving one another"
which means they are not even behaving like the disciples of Jesus as Jesus Himself desired. If only Christians, or people of any other religion for that matter, followed the primary teachings of their religion, the world would be a much better place.